HeyTaco made a simple idea popular: give everyone a few tacos a day, let them hand those tacos to coworkers in Slack, and watch a habit of saying thanks form. It works, and many teams never need anything else.
Teams usually start looking around for one of three reasons. The per-user price adds up as the company grows. Five tacos a day feels too tight, or too playful for the room. Or they want recognition to lead somewhere: to rewards people choose themselves, or to a record that says more than a count.
This guide compares four alternatives. One note before we start: Levay is our product. We put it first because we know it best, and we list its limits as plainly as everyone else's. Prices are the ones each vendor listed when we wrote this, so check their pricing pages before you decide.
Quick comparison
| App | How recognition is given | What it unlocks | Listed price | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HeyTaco | Taco emoji in a message, five a day by default | Leaderboards, levels, a reward shop | From $3 per user a month after a 30-day trial | Teams that want a light, playful habit |
| Levay | /thanks @person +amount reason, shortcuts, join buttons | Levels, a weekly top, a rewards shop you stock | Free during early access | Teams that want every thanks to carry a reason and a weight |
| Matter | Kudos cards with a weekly nudge | Coins and rewards | Free plan, then from $1 per user a month | Teams that want to start at no cost |
| Bonusly | Points with a message and a hashtag | A large rewards catalog | From $3 per user a month plus the rewards budget | Companies running a formal rewards program |
| Karma | @person ++ style karma in chat | Leaderboards and rewards | From $15 a month for 5 users | Small teams that like the classic karma model |
What HeyTaco does well
It is worth being clear about what you would be leaving.
- It is easy to explain. "You have five tacos a day" needs no onboarding.
- The daily limit is the point. A small allowance keeps people choosing who to recognize, and the limit can be changed per team.
- It lives in the chat. Recognition happens in public channels, in Slack or Microsoft Teams.
- There is more behind it than tacos. Leaderboards, levels and a shop for rewards come with the plans.
If none of the three reasons above apply to you, staying with HeyTaco is a perfectly good decision.
1. Levay
Levay on Slack is built around one command: /thanks @person +amount reason. The amount comes out of the giver's own daily allowance (50 ⭐ by default, and you set the number) and lands on the colleague's balance. The giver gets no currency back, so two people cannot farm each other. Every thanks needs a reason, and a card in the channel shows who thanked whom and for what.
What grows out of that:
- Two shortcuts. "Thank the author" thanks the person who wrote a message, right from that message, and posts the card in its thread and in the channel. "Say thanks" opens the form from anywhere.
- Join buttons. Colleagues can add their own +1, +5 or +10 under a thanks, each from their own allowance.
- App Home. A personal tab with what you received, your rank, how much you can still give today and the team's recent thanks.
- Profile cards.
/profileanswers with a picture, visible only to you. - Levels and XP. XP goes to the person who thanks, so generosity is what levels you up.
- Weekly leaderboard post. The top of the last 7 days, posted to a channel on the schedule you pick.
- Rewards. People spend what they received on codes, digital content, physical items or anything you fulfil by hand.
- Your own emoji. The currency can be any emoji, including a custom one from your workspace.
Everything is managed from a web dashboard. Every command is listed in Help & docs.
Limits. Levay does not run on Microsoft Teams. There is no gift card catalog: the rewards are the ones you add yourself. Levels are capped at five per workspace. Join buttons, levels and rewards are off until you switch them on. It is not in the Slack Marketplace yet, so you add it to your workspace from the Levay dashboard. And it is a young product in early access, with far fewer teams behind it than HeyTaco.
Price. Free throughout early access.
Best for: teams that want recognition with a reason and an amount attached, and rewards they choose themselves.
2. Matter
Matter is the usual first stop for teams leaving HeyTaco over cost. Recognition takes the form of kudos cards, and a weekly prompt nudges people to send them, which helps teams that forget.
- Free plan. Matter lists a free plan for unlimited users, with more features on its subscription tiers.
- Coins and rewards. Kudos carry coins that people redeem for rewards.
- Slack and Microsoft Teams. It runs on both.
Limits. The weekly rhythm is a different habit from HeyTaco's daily one. Check which features sit on the free plan before you plan around them.
Price. Free plan, then listed from $1 per user a month on annual billing.
Best for: small and mid-size teams that want to start at no cost.
3. Bonusly
Bonusly is the heavier option. People give each other points with a message and a hashtag, and the points are redeemed in a large rewards catalog.
- A real rewards program. The catalog and the reporting are built for HR teams that run recognition as a program.
- Slack and Microsoft Teams. Recognition can be given from chat, with more in Bonusly's own app.
Limits. The rewards budget comes on top of the subscription, so the true cost is higher than the per-user price. It is more setup than a small team needs.
Price. Listed from $3 per user a month, plus what you spend on rewards.
Best for: companies with a rewards budget and someone to run the program.
4. Karma
Karma keeps the oldest model in chat: add karma to a colleague in a message, and the bot keeps score.
- Familiar mechanics. Anyone who has used a karma bot knows how it works.
- Leaderboards and rewards. Scores feed leaderboards, and admins can set up rewards.
- Company values. Karma can be tagged with a value, which gives reports some meaning.
Limits. Pricing starts with a small team bundle, so check how it scales for your headcount.
Price. Listed from $15 a month for 5 users.
Best for: small teams that like the classic karma model.
Which one should you pick?
- You want a daily habit that needs no explaining: stay with HeyTaco.
- You want every thanks to carry a reason and an amount, and rewards you stock yourself: Levay.
- You want to start with a free plan: Matter.
- You run recognition as a company program with a budget: Bonusly.
- You want the classic karma model: Karma.
Whichever you choose, run it for a month with one team before you roll it out. Recognition tools work when managers are the first ones using them, in public and with a reason.
Ready to try the first one on the list? Get started free and see how Levay works on Slack.
Questions and answers
What is HeyTaco?
HeyTaco is a peer recognition app for Slack and Microsoft Teams. Everyone gets a small number of tacos a day to give to coworkers, and the tacos add up into leaderboards, levels and rewards.
Is there a free alternative to HeyTaco?
Yes. Matter lists a free plan for unlimited users, and Levay is free throughout early access. HeyTaco itself offers a 30-day trial and then a per-user subscription.
Why do recognition apps limit how much you can give per day?
A daily limit keeps recognition deliberate. When giving is unlimited, points lose their meaning within a few weeks. HeyTaco uses five tacos a day by default, Levay uses a daily allowance the admin sets.
Do these apps work outside Slack?
HeyTaco, Matter, Bonusly and Karma also run on Microsoft Teams. Levay runs on Slack, Discord and Telegram, each as its own separate space, and does not support Microsoft Teams.
Is Levay free?
Levay is free throughout early access.